Nippon India Multi Asset Fund

Should you invest in Nippon India Multi Asset Fund?

Nippon India has launched an NFO (New Fund Offering) for a Multi-Asset Mutual Fund. The NFO is open from 7th to 21st August 2020. We once looked at whether it makes sense for investors. We do not offer to invest in it. Its allocation to non-equity assets is marginal, and its protection selection structure for each asset class means prudence, they will have to make many decisions in order to provide these funds. We believe that the recently launched Multi-Asset Fund is a better alternative to the Nippon India Multi-Asset Fund.



What is Nippon India Multi-Asset Fund?

The primary objective of Nippon India Multi-Asset Fund is to achieve long-term capital gains by investing in equities and equity-related securities, debt and money market instruments, and exchange-traded commodity derivatives and gold ETFs from time to time.

The underlying premise is that as different asset classes (equity, debt, gold, others) outperform at different times, a basket of most inalienable assets yields better risk-consistent returns in the long run.

We’ve been rocking the resource allocation drum for some time now. We believe it serves two purposes:

Better for mental health: We (humans) cannot handle acute depression. Even if we know in our brains that despite the volatility, equity will pay higher returns in the long run, forcing people who see a portfolio in red to do fun things. Everything is like selling and cash is transferred to cut the discomfort and swear the equities. Our analysis shows that even the combination of Nifty with FDs would have yielded similar returns for much less volatility.

"In uncertain times like today, the awareness that no matter how deep the correction is, a portion of your investment will remain blocked and growing, can make the difference between losing the plot and making the right decision." [Forget share, get your asset allocation right]


Better for long-term returns: In contrast to giving returns for protection, a properly diversified basket of assets can help any single asset to achieve more success than much less volatility. To test the effect of the results, we examined it by combining the domestic equity portfolio with gold, international equities.

"The goal of an investor is to allocate the least possible amount of risky assets when fulfilling his annual return in the long run".


How have multi-asset funds performed?

The table shows the historic historical performance of multi-asset funds in India.

Typically, when you compare the funds of a department, you see the positive and negative edges of the scale clustering strongly around the central average with a few externalities. But with multi-asset funding, you have a significant spread over performance across all time-frames and over a particular year.

If you are not told that they all fund in the same department, there is no reason to believe they had any overlap in their investment strategy.

The reason is that most multi-asset funds are really “equity and a bit” funds. In the table below we have repeatedly checked the top asset allocation strategies of large multi asset funds and their top holdings.

Each fund has a higher limit of 80% for equity. The top three funds in the table have much lower allocations in the non-equity asset category, ranging from 10 to 30%. This makes them more “equity-and-bit funds” rather than “multi-asset funds”.

The fourth fund, SBI Multi-Asset Fund, has given maximum flexibility in how it has created its target allocation. We think it’s good and bad.

The good reason this means that it has been able to be 35% of the allocation to GSE as opposed to what other funds can do, which is a significant allocation for t.


Worse because it all comes down to the judgment and time of the fund manager. And as bright as they can be, above all they are human. When equities roar, it is normal for equity allocations to flow as the maximum allowed because


Nippon India Multi-Asset Fund: Whatever we like

A multi-asset strategy is just as effective as a basket of assets. Most multi-asset funds in India consider only Indian equity.

We are convinced of the need for international diversification in the portfolio of Indian investors. The Nippon India Multi Asset Fund will have a significant allocation of ~ 20% to companies outside India.

Of these, 65% will be in the United States, 20% in Japan and Europe, and 15% in others. So far so good.


The lower limit for domestic + international equity is significantly lower than the 50 existing multimillion-dollar resource funds, but there is a marginal target allocation for non-equity components. It would have been prudent to have the right mix at any given time, to have more freedom in debt and product allocation.


Too much reliance on prudent decisions

Multi-asset funds rely on the discipline of maintaining uncontrolled assets in the mix to provide higher risk-consistent returns. To minimize the impact of prudent decisions they are best to keep the minimum spending basket of security within each asset class.


What securities in each asset class

The domestic equity selection framework says it will use the bottom-up approach to find stocks with a gap between fair price and market value.

The international equity selection will select 25 stocks, 15 in the United States, 5 in Europe, and 5 stocks from other parts of the world.

The product selection framework says “flexibility in investing in different products to provide diversity among products”. It follows that “investment will basically turn into gold”.

And finally, the fixed income component will try to choose a medium duration profile centered on stable returns with moderate volatility.

In order for this fund to deliver its higher risk-inclusive return, many of the fund managers need to make the right decisions.


Conclusion

It is great to see multiple asset funds begin to add meaningful internationalization, which creates a more powerful asset basket.

However the low allocation of non-equity and the completely isolated nature of each decision means that the fund managers have to get everything right for the provision of this fund. In our opinion, the best approach is to buy a low-value basket representing the entire market within each asset class and manage the allocation as the main driver of performance.

Motilal Oswal Multi Asset Fund is a better option. It converts gold to gold with S&P 500 ETFs and gives flexibility to go into almost complete debt. While this fund has its swallows, we think it’s a better way to get in touch with multiple assets in your portfolio.

Previous
Next Post »